Manager: Roberto's own thread
+44
big ming
Dions_Bald_Head
Thinman
mefromhere
Saunders82
CoE82
Dazzle
Synopsis
UnclePanda
Aston Phila
Con
TheVillansOfAston
Terry Derry
danclare82
AstonThriller
Army villain
Villa_Dan
DelboyVilla
VTID85
FoxyAV
andrew24561
BillytheKid
VillaBill
deadbuzzardalive
KMitch
avfc85
Fpuppys
avfc forever
NARLA24
Dgrizzle7
Villa Ranger
Boldfinger
Cha Ching
Wriggle
1Elliot
The Utterer
DaveAV1
jeffvilla
4BetLite
Trotters
Mr_Spadge
Lammypaul
De Kuip
smetro
48 posters
Page 6 of 16
Page 6 of 16 • 1 ... 5, 6, 7 ... 11 ... 16
Should he stay or should he go?
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
Villa_Dan wrote:Could Richards do a job in midfeld?
To be honest at this level, we should be able to put someone in there. For all his faults Gardner has 2 season experience in midfield at this division. Lyden is a promising youngster. A lot of clubs are fielding youngsters and free transfers in there midfield. I quite like the look of Tishbola - but I honestly don't think his inclusion would have got us 3 points tonight. IMO its either...
1.)The Team is taking time to bed in
or
2.) RDM hasn't got what it takes to mould and prepare these group of players into a decent team.
No 2 is significantly more likley IMO.
smetro- Posts : 2831
Reputation : 1483
Join date : 2014-12-26
Age : 60
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
I've asked just the same in the past. But he's got a whiff of headless chicken about him but as long as we have injury issues, players like Gardner and "but look at the statistics Westwood" then it's maybe worth considering.
But RDM has to first understand the concept of what a midfield actually does and I'm not sure he gets this. It's bizarre.
I'm now wondering if offloading Veretout and Sanchez was a bad idea. Veretout was unsettled but surely he'd settle if the results were right.
It's all such a fucking mess at the moment.
But RDM has to first understand the concept of what a midfield actually does and I'm not sure he gets this. It's bizarre.
I'm now wondering if offloading Veretout and Sanchez was a bad idea. Veretout was unsettled but surely he'd settle if the results were right.
It's all such a fucking mess at the moment.
Trotters- Posts : 9683
Reputation : 5309
Join date : 2014-03-09
Age : 52
Location : Brisbane
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
Trotters wrote:I've asked just the same in the past. But he's got a whiff of headless chicken about him but as long as we have injury issues, players like Gardner and "but look at the statistics Westwood" then it's maybe worth considering.
But RDM has to first understand the concept of what a midfield actually does and I'm not sure he gets this. It's bizarre.
I'm now wondering if offloading Veretout and Sanchez was a bad idea. Veretout was unsettled but surely he'd settle if the results were right.
It's all such a fucking mess at the moment.
come on - I know things are bad - but calling for the return of Veretout ? - jesus wept....
smetro- Posts : 2831
Reputation : 1483
Join date : 2014-12-26
Age : 60
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
He's better than fresh air which is all we have in midfield at the moment. And is there anyone that thinks that had we thrown Sanchez on after Gestede's goal last weekend that we'd have lost?
It seems to me that RDM doesn't trust the reserve midfielders that he has available so would rather just use 2 rather than the tradional 4 (or even 3). That's just bananas.
It seems to me that RDM doesn't trust the reserve midfielders that he has available so would rather just use 2 rather than the tradional 4 (or even 3). That's just bananas.
Trotters- Posts : 9683
Reputation : 5309
Join date : 2014-03-09
Age : 52
Location : Brisbane
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
I've always preferred Sanchez to Westwood, yes he gives the odd ball away but at least he can tackle well, and certainly think he would have been a great option coming off the bench when we are shoring things up.
Wriggle- Posts : 416
Reputation : 385
Join date : 2014-08-17
Age : 52
Location : Australia
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
I was looking at DiMatteo lamenting that errors have led to us dropping points late on in matches and it led me to wonder how come we never seem to benefit from opposition errors if that was the case. I mean these things balance out over a season.
The answer is obvious to me. We are not taking the game to the opposition so we don't create chances. I'd love to see a chances created and conceded table after 80 minutes for our games. It would show Roberto what he needs to change.
The answer is obvious to me. We are not taking the game to the opposition so we don't create chances. I'd love to see a chances created and conceded table after 80 minutes for our games. It would show Roberto what he needs to change.
Cha Ching- Posts : 431
Reputation : 316
Join date : 2014-04-16
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
I was at the match and I could not believe the change from the first half and the second. I agree that the ginger did run the midfield, this was only because he went for EVERY ball near him. We always lost the second ball when it was played out, they wanted the ball more !!. I feel that if we fight for EVERY ball and make it difficult for opposition's player to settle we will get the bloody ball back.
I still feel that we lack passion and the tactics in the second half were shocking, no major attempts at goal defend defend defend. We need to take the sword to the other teams not get one goal and hope for the best, we need passion fight and commitment to get our might Villa back to where we should be.
I still feel that we lack passion and the tactics in the second half were shocking, no major attempts at goal defend defend defend. We need to take the sword to the other teams not get one goal and hope for the best, we need passion fight and commitment to get our might Villa back to where we should be.
jeffvilla- Posts : 745
Reputation : 396
Join date : 2014-04-16
Age : 67
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
I don't think RDM will be under any real pressure from DrX at the moment, they said before the season started there aim was to get back to prem as soon as possible within the next couple of seasons so I expect he will be fine up to about Christmas, if we aren't mid table by then I could perhaps see something happening.
Tony himself said the squad was in a much worse state than they were lead to believe and the people around him will surely have let him know what a task it would be which is why he has spent what he has in my opinion.
I wouldn't worry too much about FFP, there is very little incentive to keep from breaking the rules truth be told and I am sure with as many companies as there appears in the Recon Group that there are plenty of sponsorship deals that can be arranged to circumvent them if it is needed.
Tony himself said the squad was in a much worse state than they were lead to believe and the people around him will surely have let him know what a task it would be which is why he has spent what he has in my opinion.
I wouldn't worry too much about FFP, there is very little incentive to keep from breaking the rules truth be told and I am sure with as many companies as there appears in the Recon Group that there are plenty of sponsorship deals that can be arranged to circumvent them if it is needed.
Synopsis- Posts : 456
Reputation : 466
Join date : 2014-05-16
Location : Dundee
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
The club may well have been in a worse state than they imagined but, on the pitch at least, no stone was left unturned and no cheque was left unwritten to fix this.
I'm pretty sure we have a squad that's at least a top 6 finisher. And maybe we'll get there; win at Ipswich and turn the Toon over and the season suddenly looks very different indeed.
I just don't see that happening. I don't see any week in week improvement. The "gelling" ain't happening and can't happen if he's playing people out of position and just being completely random about things.
He'll be feeling the pressure for this weekend that's fo sho. There are 4 groups that can lose faith in the manager:
- the fans: we're already seeing signs.
- the players: interesting that he came out VERY early after half time against Brentford and left the players to it.
- the media: will largely go with the feeling of the crowd but the more intelligent journos will offer something to think about.
- the board: the be all, end all.
A loss against Ipswich (especially in the last 10 mins) and I can see things turning against him from all over.
I'm pretty sure we have a squad that's at least a top 6 finisher. And maybe we'll get there; win at Ipswich and turn the Toon over and the season suddenly looks very different indeed.
I just don't see that happening. I don't see any week in week improvement. The "gelling" ain't happening and can't happen if he's playing people out of position and just being completely random about things.
He'll be feeling the pressure for this weekend that's fo sho. There are 4 groups that can lose faith in the manager:
- the fans: we're already seeing signs.
- the players: interesting that he came out VERY early after half time against Brentford and left the players to it.
- the media: will largely go with the feeling of the crowd but the more intelligent journos will offer something to think about.
- the board: the be all, end all.
A loss against Ipswich (especially in the last 10 mins) and I can see things turning against him from all over.
Trotters- Posts : 9683
Reputation : 5309
Join date : 2014-03-09
Age : 52
Location : Brisbane
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
RDM wrote:
"I don’t think we can play with six strikers. We need to find the right players for the right games and try to win."
Trotters- Posts : 9683
Reputation : 5309
Join date : 2014-03-09
Age : 52
Location : Brisbane
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
Trotters wrote:RDM wrote:
"I don’t think we can play with six strikers. We need to find the right players for the right games and try to win."
lol. its also true when he says that he hasn't had that long with ALL the players so admits he's trying to find a balance. better than saying "look, we go again"
Guest- Guest
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
That close enough for ya?
Trotters- Posts : 9683
Reputation : 5309
Join date : 2014-03-09
Age : 52
Location : Brisbane
Villa_Dan- Posts : 4425
Reputation : 4106
Join date : 2014-05-13
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
I really would do the deed now. Really what is more games going to show us ?
smetro- Posts : 2831
Reputation : 1483
Join date : 2014-12-26
Age : 60
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
jimbop wrote:Trotters wrote:RDM wrote:
"I don’t think we can play with six strikers. We need to find the right players for the right games and try to win."
lol. its also true when he says that he hasn't had that long with ALL the players so admits he's trying to find a balance. better than saying "look, we go again"
My you're easily pleased !
Its when not if - I really don't see the sense hanging about.
smetro- Posts : 2831
Reputation : 1483
Join date : 2014-12-26
Age : 60
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
I'm dreading the game against the noses now.
As for RDM,. I agree Dan. He might get away with losing to Newcastle next round - although you have to look at our last result against them and ask why, when their chairman has effectively asset-stripped them while ours broke the bank. After that though, I don't think he'll have any place to hide when Tony comes calling.
As for RDM,. I agree Dan. He might get away with losing to Newcastle next round - although you have to look at our last result against them and ask why, when their chairman has effectively asset-stripped them while ours broke the bank. After that though, I don't think he'll have any place to hide when Tony comes calling.
Trotters- Posts : 9683
Reputation : 5309
Join date : 2014-03-09
Age : 52
Location : Brisbane
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
I am willing to give Roberto more time but it is getting slightly frustrating because he is not seeing what is so obvious, we were overloading our attack instead of creating a balanced team, our formation isnt working - fed up of playing Grealish and Ayew as inside forwards as they never go wide just always come in so easy to read for opposition. The fact that we still continue with Westwood I would rather play Lyden over him and get Green back.
avfc85- Posts : 519
Reputation : 325
Join date : 2014-12-07
Age : 39
Location : Birmingham
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
Green looked to be our best option on the right. Very tidy, very composed. I was genuinely excited for the lad this season. But he's obviously been overlooked.
Trotters- Posts : 9683
Reputation : 5309
Join date : 2014-03-09
Age : 52
Location : Brisbane
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
Trotters wrote:Green looked to be our best option on the right. Very tidy, very composed. I was genuinely excited for the lad this season. But he's obviously been overlooked.
All the youth players are being overlooked so it seems?
DelboyVilla- Posts : 1453
Reputation : 1337
Join date : 2014-05-14
Age : 54
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
I believe if we're not totally sunk into the relegation places within the next four or five games then he deserves a run until Xmas and then we can assess things. The question I have in my mind is how many managers have we had over the years who have started poor and then made us decent? Houllier was in a relegation battle for much of his season and then we ended up finishing ninth.
In Dol's first season we started off crap and then with the signing of Nobby we just flew up the table and almost got top four. We just have to wait and see what RDM is made of over these next run of games. To be fair we should have won all of our home games so it's not all going west, he just needs a little luck.
In Dol's first season we started off crap and then with the signing of Nobby we just flew up the table and almost got top four. We just have to wait and see what RDM is made of over these next run of games. To be fair we should have won all of our home games so it's not all going west, he just needs a little luck.
Last edited by AstonThriller on Sun Sep 18, 2016 9:46 pm; edited 1 time in total
AstonThriller- Posts : 2166
Reputation : 1749
Join date : 2014-04-21
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
This is what I hate more than anything in modern football. The demand of instant results. Just ridiculous even debating sacking RDM.
We had the same problems with Sherwood, and quite simply you need a lot of time to settle down a new group of players.
Even Man Utd with their billion quid purchases aren't debating sacking Mourinho despite being shite.
We had the same problems with Sherwood, and quite simply you need a lot of time to settle down a new group of players.
Even Man Utd with their billion quid purchases aren't debating sacking Mourinho despite being shite.
Guest- Guest
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
Oh they are! I've seen more than a few comments on social media calling for his head.
Trotters- Posts : 9683
Reputation : 5309
Join date : 2014-03-09
Age : 52
Location : Brisbane
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
Was just thinking about how the other new managers are doing and it's quite interesting..
Jaap Stam at Reading = 4 wins, 2 draws and 2 defeats = 8th position
Walter Zenga at Wolves = 3 wins, 3 draws and 2 defeats= 10th position
Philippe Montanier at Forest= 3 wins, 2 draws and 3 defeats= 13th position
Gary Monk at Leeds= 3 wins, 1 draw and 4 defeats= 15th position
Roberto Di-Matteo at Villa= 1 win, 5 draws and 2 defeats= 18th position
Nigel Pearson at Derby= 1 win, 3 draws and 4 defeats= 20th position
Alan Stubbs at Rotherham= 1 win, 2 draws and 4 defeats= 21st position
Paul Trollope at Cardiff= 1 win, 2 draws and 5 defeats= 23rd position
Owen Coyle at Blackburn= 1 win, 2 draws and 5 defeats= last position
So none of the managers appointed in the summer are in the play-off positions currently. Granted none of them has spent as much as RDM but as Huddersfield are showing having a settled, well drilled side can be very effective too. I wonder if it's a coincidence that all of the top seven teams had their managers in place from last season? Who knows.
Jaap Stam at Reading = 4 wins, 2 draws and 2 defeats = 8th position
Walter Zenga at Wolves = 3 wins, 3 draws and 2 defeats= 10th position
Philippe Montanier at Forest= 3 wins, 2 draws and 3 defeats= 13th position
Gary Monk at Leeds= 3 wins, 1 draw and 4 defeats= 15th position
Roberto Di-Matteo at Villa= 1 win, 5 draws and 2 defeats= 18th position
Nigel Pearson at Derby= 1 win, 3 draws and 4 defeats= 20th position
Alan Stubbs at Rotherham= 1 win, 2 draws and 4 defeats= 21st position
Paul Trollope at Cardiff= 1 win, 2 draws and 5 defeats= 23rd position
Owen Coyle at Blackburn= 1 win, 2 draws and 5 defeats= last position
So none of the managers appointed in the summer are in the play-off positions currently. Granted none of them has spent as much as RDM but as Huddersfield are showing having a settled, well drilled side can be very effective too. I wonder if it's a coincidence that all of the top seven teams had their managers in place from last season? Who knows.
AstonThriller- Posts : 2166
Reputation : 1749
Join date : 2014-04-21
Re: Manager: Roberto's own thread
I think your posts are very good AT, but if you fancy comparing things.. I'd compare how teams do after replacing such a big part of their playing squad as we've done. Like PDC with Sunderland
Guest- Guest
Page 6 of 16 • 1 ... 5, 6, 7 ... 11 ... 16
Similar topics
» Next Aston Villa manager thread
» The general Match thread thread when people cba or forget to make one
» Burnley V Aston Villa, all inclusive plus sun beds thread and free drinks, only local brands mind you, type thread
» You're the manager
» Next Manager - I want names
» The general Match thread thread when people cba or forget to make one
» Burnley V Aston Villa, all inclusive plus sun beds thread and free drinks, only local brands mind you, type thread
» You're the manager
» Next Manager - I want names
Page 6 of 16
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|